Media Release: Who is Paying for BN's Manifesto Campaign?



As elections draw nearer, the Center to Combat Corruption and Cronyism (C4 Center) notes with grave concern that the acts of money politics continue unabated despite the fact that they are criminalised under the Election Offences Act 1954 (EOA). 

C4 Center started monitoring and documenting cases of money politics after the dissolution of Parliament on 7 April 2018 and as of now, we have documented more than 22 cases ranging from treating and bribery to undue influence.

We also note that digital media is increasingly used for election campaigning and it is inevitable to ask this important question: who is paying for this campaign strategy? 

 C4 Center would like to highlight a glaring example of a highly questionable campaign strategy employed by the Barisan Nasional (BN) where premium advertisements are being put up on multiple high-profile Malaysian websites. 

Based on our observation, we found no less than ten high-profile websites carrying these digital advertisements. According to media professionals, this kind of digital advertisement would estimate around RM150,000.00 a week per website (RM6 million for 10 sites).

We also note the surge in the number of bots on Twitter generating anti-opposition and pro-government messages. Media professionals estimate hundreds of thousand ringgit being spent to run digital campaigns using bots. 

It is important to highlight that section 19 of the EOA makes it illegal for candidates or their election agents to spend more than RM200,000.00 (election to Dewan Rakyat) and RM100,000.00 (election to Legislative Assembly). 

The amount of money involved in this digital campaign is undoubtedly substantial. 

This begs the questions – Where does the money come from? Is this from our national budget? Are taxpayers footing the bill? Who funds these initiatives? 

It is noteworthy that Malaysia’s deeply embedded culture of money politics is closely linked to the absence of transparent and accountable political financing laws to regulate the conduct of political parties in sourcing funds to run their party activities and sustain the party’s survival particularly during election period. 

The absence of political financing framework would further empower and embolden the culture of money politics, thus making the quest for accountability and transparency an uphill battle. 

Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Paul Low’s initiative to formulate a political financing framework is unjustifiably delayed and this goes to show that the whole initiative is nothing but a sham. It is clear as day that the ruling party does not have the political will to realise the pressing obligation to uphold accountability around political financing and money politics. 

We reiterate that the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission and Election Commission have an obligation to combat these acts of corrupt practices. Their silence in the face of this blatant violation of electoral fairness and integrity is extremely appalling. 

In light of this, C4 demands:

1)    All parties to put a stop to vote buying and using the media for campaign advertisements
2)    All parties to commit to legislating the political financing law without undue delay.

Only then can we hope to have a clean-up of our tainted and corrupt system.

Released By

Cynthia Gabriel & Fadiah Nadwa
Executive Director & Legal Researcher