C4 Press Statement: Former Lawmaker’s Irresponsible Food Dumping Highlights Ignorance in Food Security and Waste Management Issues.

24 APRIL 2024


Former Lawmaker’s Irresponsible Food Dumping Highlights Ignorance in Food Security and Waste Management Issues. 

The Center to Combat Corruption and Cronyism (C4 Center) is astounded by the recent revelation of former Kuala Krau Member of Parliament (MP) Ismail Mohamed Said’s disposal of a massive amount of staple food including rice, sardines, flour, and other food items at a dumpsite in Temerloh, Pahang. Videos of the discarded items in a dumpsite were circulated on social media, infuriating the general public. Following that, Ismail, who is also a former Deputy Home Minister, issued a statement on April 19th, admitting to discarding the food items and explaining that they had been stored for a long time and were now contaminated and unsafe for human consumption.  

Nevertheless, his actions raise several pertinent questions of governance that must be answered. Firstly, why was such a substantial amount of food stored for so long that it expired? Ismail stated that the food stocks were procured in 2022 before GE-15 and stored as it is prohibited to distribute goods to the public during campaign period. However, why wasn’t the food distributed to the constituency after the election? Was this influenced by his loss in the contest? His actions, especially amidst a national rice shortage, raise serious concerns as to whether this practice occurs in other constituencies in Malaysia. 

In addition, discarding food items in an allegedly illegal landfill area is negligent and unacceptable from a former MP and minister. It is not sufficient to merely accept responsibility for the disposal and express regret, as Ismail had done so in his statement. The action of illegal disposal of waste can be charged under the Solid Waste and Public Cleansing Management Act 2007, which carries a fine from RM10,000 to a maximum of RM100,000, or a jail term of six months to five years, or both. Not only that, some of the items in the dumpsite seen in the circulated videos were burned, which is a crime under the Environmental Quality Act 1974 where an offender can be fined a maximum of RM500,000 or jail term of up to 5 years, or both. Both of these actions are egregious considering Malaysia is already dealing with existing illegal dumping and waste management issues. C4 Center’s report, “Malaysia is not a garbage dump: Citizens against corruption, complacency, and climate crisis”, uncovered the major challenges facing Malaysia’s waste management, especially since China’s 2019 ban on waste imports which led to it being redirected to Malaysia and other Southeast Asian countries. 

Furthermore, early investigations by Pahang Solid Waste and Public Cleansing Management Corporation (SWCorp) have found that the dumpsite is not gazetted as a garbage disposal site. Had this incident not been exposed, the massive piles of food waste and their packaging would deteriorate and contaminate the surrounding environment, affecting waterways, land, and air, negatively affecting the health and livelihood of local communities. 

As a former lawmaker, Ismail should have known of the impact of his actions. He and his team should have worked together with waste management agencies such as SWCorp, along with the Padi and Rice Supervision Section (KPB) under the Agriculture and Food Security Ministry (KPKM) to dispose of the rice. Moreover, the Cabinet members should have taken more prompt and serious action on this matter. 

Hence, C4 Center strongly urges the government to:

  1. Take action on the former MP and ensure Ismail and his team is accountable for the clean up of the dumpsite and dispose of the food waste in an environmentally sound manner. 
  2. Incorporate measurable, inclusive and sustainable targets into the National Blueprint on Solid Waste Management and Circularity to address domestic waste management issues. 
  3. Incorporate proper accountability and transparency procedures in procurement involving a substantial amount of controlled items.
  4. Strengthen enforcement in waste management and enhance monitoring systems to prevent illegal dumping from occurring.
  5. Enhance public participation through public complaints systems for the general public to report any suspicious and illegal incidents. 


Issued by:
Center to Combat Corruption & Cronyism (C4 Center)
For further enquiries, please contact:
019-216 6218
Website: https://c4center.org




All publications by C4 Center are downloadable for free. Much resources and funds have been put into ensuring that we conduct cutting edge research work for these issues to be brought to the attention of the general public, authorities, as well as public policymakers and lawmakers. If you like our work, please do consider supporting us by donating to us. Your financial support will go a long way in ensuring that we can continue fighting for a clean, and better, Malaysia.